Original Designs, Expertly Baked
Creating custom sugar cookies that are as delightful to look at as they are to eat. Our cookies bring a touch of charm and elegance to every event—birthday party, wedding, baby shower, or corporate gathering.
Custom Cookies for Every Occasion
CLICK HERE
TAKE A LOOK AT MY WORK
CLICK HERE
READY TO GET STARTED?
CLICK HERE
HAVE QUESTIONS? GET THE ANSWERS
I'm a passionate cookie decorator with over 10 years of experience bringing sweet visions to life, one cookie at a time. Based in sunny Arizona, I live with my husband and our two kids, who are my biggest taste-testers and supporters. When I’m not decorating cookies I’m either outside running through the desert or inside throwing ceramic plates and bowls.
I would love to make cookies for you!
Hi, I’m Lindsey
"Simply perfect in EVERY way!! Crazy beautiful artistry on top of a delicious cookie! Three dozen cookies and three dozen unique adorable designs. The debate has begun...too pretty to eat vs too good not to eat? They all arrived at the prearranged time for my custom order in perfect condition. Well packed and a fantastic price for such a high end experience. I highly recommend."
"Well packed and a fantastic price for such a high end experience. I highly recommend."
kate
"I was searching for a baker to create cookies that emulate our intricate designs for a while and many bakers said no. Sweet 17 was able to exceed our expectations and I could tell she enjoyed doing it. I've already put in my second order."
"Sweet 17 was able to exceed our expectations and I could tell she enjoyed doing it."
andre
"These cookies are beautiful! You could tell time was taken with the icing because the designs were flawless. They will be perfect in my gift baskets! They arrived exactly when I requested them, and they were packaged well to prevent breakage. Thank you!"
"You could tell time was taken with the icing because the designs were flawless."
jc
"To say these cookies were amazing, is a huge understatement. The decoration was extraordinarily detailed, flawless! I messaged Lindsey with a special request on a whim... With zero hesitation she accepted my request and agreed to make us two different designs! Unbelievable customer service! Look no further for the best custom cookies available and the best experience on Etsy!"
"With zero hesitation she accepted my request... Not to mention the salted caramel cookies were delicious!."
nycgatita
"These cookies are absolutely beautiful and are a focal point on my ofrenda. I will definitely be ordering from this seller again. The cookies arrived securely packaged and fresh! I enjoyed all communication with the vendor -- very personable and enthusiastic. I would give her six stars if I could!"
"I would give her six stars if I could!"
john
View My Work
COOKIE ART
For pick up and delivery, cookies are placed on a platter which gets wrapped in a cellophane bag. Cookies can be bagged in a cellophane bag, either heat-sealed or tied with a ribbon for an additional cost. Cookies that are shipped are bagged in a heat-sealed cellophane bag and boxed with plenty of bubble wrap.
No, but please note my kitchen is not nut free.
Not at this time.
Frequently
Asked Questions
Frequently Asked Questions
Regular sized (3”-5”) custom cookies start at $6.00. Factors including flavor, delivery choice, packaging, and design choices can increase price.
The happiest moments of my day are spent with a bag of royal icing.
For over a decade, Lindsey has been perfecting the art of cookie decorating, bringing creativity and precision to every order. As her family moved across the country, she carried her passion from kitchen to kitchen. What began as a hobby quickly turned into a heartfelt pursuit, blending whimsical designs with professional skill. Today, her cookies reflect not just experience, but the stories, inspiration, and joy gathered along the way.
Cookie decorating magic by a master designer
Let’s create your perfect cookie
Designed just the way you want it. With over 17 delicious flavors to choose from and endless custom design possibilities, your cookies will be as unique as the occasion they are made for. Whether you are celebrating a baby shower, planning a wedding, hosting a corporate event, or simply treating yourself, we tailor each order to fit your vision and taste. With intricate hand-piped details every cookie is made with care, creativity, and the highest quality ingredients. No matter the moment, we’re here to make it sweeter—one custom cookie at a time.
The Design Process
What to expect
In the Phoenix area? Your cookies can be delivered or picked up. Not local? No problem, I’ll ship the cookies to you or anyplace you need them to go.
Get ahold of me so we can start building your order. We’ll discuss how many cookies you need, what designs you would like, and when you will need the cookies. This is when you get to choose your flavors!
This is when I get to work planning and sketching your cookies. You can always request a digital mock-up.
It’s time to start baking and decorating. Every cookie is rolled out, decorated, and packed by hand, my hands to be exact!
Please include how many cookies you are looking to order and any design details you desire. Cookies can be delivered, picked up, or shipped. I will respond to your email in 2-3 days.
